The high-profile performances of Ok-Pop acts BLACKPINK and LE SSERAFIM at Coachella all through the years have been met with a important appraisal from famend music critic Kim Do Heon, sparking a heated dialogue amongst followers.
BLACKPINK’s inaugural 2019 Coachella set was met with combined emotions from Kim, who discovered their dwell vocals underwhelming. Despite this, he acknowledged that the group’s efficiency embodied the pageant’s eclectic spirit.
BLACKPINK is performing dwell at Coachella. It’s actually stunning {that a} Ok-Pop lady group is acting at Coachella… however their singing is kind of poor. The decadent environment and the chaotic EDM hybrid do appear to set the temper properly although, don’t they?
— Kim Do Heon
However, when revisiting BLACKPINK’s return as headliners in 2023, Kim’s assessment took on a sharper edge. He criticized the group for lacking a big cultural alternative to current a story as wealthy and impactful as their predecessors on the Coachella stage. He remarked on the dearth of depth and the failure to grab the second to characterize Asian artists meaningfully or to contribute to the narrative of Ok-Pop as a reputable different music style.
“If that they had severely embraced the importance of being a Coachella headliner, such a superficial and light-weight method wouldn’t have emerged. It shouldn’t have simply been a stage to showcase how fairly and well-known BLACKPINK is. As the primary Ok-Pop, and certainly the primary Asian feminine group to be headliners at an American pageant, there was a lot narrative potential to attract from. Yesterday, Bad Bunny, the primary Latin American artist to headline, packed his 25-song setlist with a lecture on the historical past of Latin music, a report highlighting the dire state of affairs in his native Puerto Rico, and his private narrative as a musician. The world realized the depth of Latin music and its legitimacy as different music, and acknowledged his celebrity standing.
What did Blackpink’s efficiency depart behind? A logo of the Asian growth in America? The solidarity amongst ladies that the earlier performer, Boygenius, demonstrated? The Ok-Pop system that made their right this moment attainable? The risk of Ok-Pop as a brand new different music? Nothing remained. It was simply one in every of many busy schedules they managed to deal with.”
— Kim Do Heon
[HD] @BLACKPINK at Coachella week 2. (8)
Via. Getty Images (no watermark)#BLACKPINKxCoachella #PINKCHELLA pic.twitter.com/C9APB6eXVP
— BLACKPINK Global News (@BPGlobalNews) April 23, 2023
The scathing assessment lamented what he perceived as a step again from their earlier Coachella efficiency, suggesting that the stage was a missed likelihood for Ok-pop to determine a critical foothold within the international music scene.
“Since the aim was easy, it inevitably led to discussions of expertise. Compared to the quite a few artists who threw themselves into the Coachella stage, Blackpink was completely not on the stage to be pageant headliners. The early elements of their efficiency, the place they added AR and backing vocals, had been horrible. They didn’t even dance as passionately because the backup dancers. Only when contemplating the scale of the viewers, the dazzling gadgets, the drone present adorning the evening sky, and the preparations fitted to a big stage, may one understand this efficiency was a spotlight. The format, shifting from group songs to particular person member solos, would have sufficed for a home idol live performance. It was a efficiency appropriate for social media uploads, DVD releases.
It regressed in each side in comparison with 2019. Blackpink’s Coachella stage ended with a spectacular fireworks show. It momentarily dazzled everybody, however quickly left solely acrid smoke behind in the dead of night house. It was a waste of a stage that each musician goals of. Ok-Pop missed a critical alternative to be handled earnestly on the worldwide market.”
— Kim Do Heon
In 2024, LE SSERAFIM took the stage, and whereas Kim famous the group’s effort to current a dynamic efficiency, he additionally noticed an obvious lack of power as their set progressed. His commentary centered on the group’s technique to leverage sturdy band accompaniment to masks vocal weaknesses and produce a extra sturdy sound. This tactic, nevertheless, was not sufficient to dispel his observations of the group’s tense efficiency.
What you anticipate at Coachella will not be ‘good singing’ however moderately a dynamic efficiency that may solely be proven at this pageant. A technique that hides weaknesses and enhances strengths is required. LE SSERAFIM, maybe aware of debates over vocal capacity, had a robust band accompaniment and made the sound highly effective, however because the efficiency went on, they appeared to lose power and regarded tense.
— Kim Do Heon
Kim’s opinions have stirred a dialog across the expectations for worldwide Ok-Pop acts acting at a pageant as distinguished as Coachella. His opinions that whereas good singing might not be the hallmark of Coachella, the essence lies in delivering a memorable efficiency that performs to an artist’s strengths.
Share This Post
Source: www.koreaboo.com